the Sky Crawlers is the latest animation feature from Mamoru Oshii, that's more bound by the gravity than offering the thrill of flying in the sky as the poster would like to imply. The film spends most of its time on the earth except for the brief but exciting dogfight scenes in the blue, imaginary European sky. The introspective shots have lengthened even compare to his prior work,
Ghost in the Shell 2. He even goes as far as borrowing characters' names from his previous films, that left me wondering if he's dwelling in his past glories, summoning the ghosts of his excellent works.
The overall story is sadly disappointing on many levels despite expressionless but interesting characters and plot elements. I certainly hooked and wished to learn more about 'Kildren' and the world that perpetuates battles in the sky. But we are left with dolls, rather than humans, that are closely orchestrated by the Puppet Master rather than having their own initiatives.
It seems to me that Mamoru Oshii increasingly views himself as a puppet master since
Ghost in the Shell. You can control everything and impose your will on everything in animations unlike live action films, hence I consider creating identifiable human characters in animations far more difficult than people realize. It goes beyond human tendency to anthropomorphizing everything. In the end, I felt like Mamoru Oshii was fending off my effort to identify with main characters by their unblinking eyes & guarded dialogues. They were featured in Mamoru Oshii's previous works, but never they have been as prevalent as this film.
I was finally intrigued by the plight of main characters in the beginning of
act 3, only to be stripped away by the last dogfight scene that defied
my comprehension. In the end, despite lengthy 2 hours of running time, the film ends without satisfying emotional payoff or comprehendable conclusion.
It was disheartening to watch an unsatisfying animation with all the artistry went into making it as a diehard Mamoru Oshii fan. I hope that he'll find new joy and perspective in life, and venture to new theme beyond 'Peace is an illusion between wars.'